1821 Norfolk and Long Island hurricane
The 1821 Norfolk and Long Island Hurricane was an intense and record breaking tropical cyclone that devastated the East Coast of the United States in early September and was one of four known tropical cyclones that have made landfall in New York City. It has been estimated that a similar hurricane would cause about $250 billion in damages if such a storm were to occur in 2014.
Source: Wikipedia — 1821 Norfolk and Long Island hurricane (CC BY-SA 4.0)