1867 San Narciso hurricane
The San Narciso Hurricane was a record-breaking, extremely deadly Atlantic hurricane that caused devastation to the British Virgin Islands and Puerto Rico in 1867. Forming abnormally late for a Lesser Antilles hurricane, it went on to be the costliest and deadliest storm of the 1867 Atlantic hurricane season.
Source: Wikipedia — 1867 San Narciso hurricane (CC BY-SA 4.0)